The ethical trilemma of unclaimed cryopreserved embryos: an effective altruism framework

Article Sidebar

PDF (English)

Main Article Content

Adrian Villalba
Université Paris Cité, Paris, France | Universidad de Granada, Granada, Spain | GIBIO - Bioethics Research Group, International University of Valencia, Spain

Unclaimed embryos are cryopreserved embryos created through assisted reproductive technologies that remain in storage, typically because the individuals who created them are no longer using or actively claiming them. These embryos present a significant ethical challenge, as indefinite storage is unsustainable. This article addresses the trilemma of what to do with unclaimed embryos: whether to discard them, donate them to other couples seeking fertility treatment, or use them for scientific research. To resolve this trilemma, the principles of effective altruism —which focus on using resources to maximize positive impact for the greatest number of people— are applied to evaluate each option. The analysis concludes that donating unclaimed embryos for research is the most ethically sound choice, as it offers substantial social benefits through advancements in stem cell therapy, genetic research, and other medical fields. While discarding or donating embryos for adoption holds moral value, research provides the greatest potential for long-term improvements in human health and well-being. This article calls for legal and ethical reforms to support research on unclaimed embryos, encouraging a shift in reproductive medicine that reflects contemporary ethical priorities and scientific opportunities.

Paraules clau
unclaimed embryos, abandoned embryos, embryo donation, embryo cryopreservation, effective altruism, bioethics of reproduction

Article Details

Com citar
Villalba, Adrian. «The ethical trilemma of unclaimed cryopreserved embryos: an effective altruism framework». Ramon Llull Journal of Applied Ethics, 2025, núm. 16, doi:10.60940/rljae16Id433110.
Drets

(c) © Càtedra Ethos - Universitat Ramon Llull i Herder, 2025

Referències

Abreu, C. W. D. P. A., Abreu, M. L. A., Abreu, M. M. A., Abreu, J. P. A., Silva, L. F. C., Cruzeiro, I. K. D. C., & Nunes, R. M. L. (2021). Final destination of surplus cryopreserved embryos. What decision should be made? Jornal Brasileiro de Reproducao Assistida, 25(2), 276–281. https://doi.org/10.5935/1518-0557.20200085

Blasimme, A., & Sugarman, J. (2023). Human stem cell-derived embryo models: Toward ethically appropriate regulations and policies. Cell Stem Cell, 30(8), 1008–1012. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.STEM.2023.06.007

Bosch, E., De Vos, M., & Humaidan, P. (2020). The Future of Cryopreservation in Assisted Reproductive Technologies. Frontiers in Endocrinology, 11, 67. https://doi.org/10.3389/FENDO.2020.00067

Cutas, D., & Smajdor, A. (2024). Keeping it in the family: reproduction beyond genetic parenthood. Journal of Medical Ethics. https://doi.org/10.1136/JME-2023-109814

Disposition of unclaimed embryos: an Ethics Committee opinion. (2021). Fertility and Sterility, 116(1), 48–53. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.FERTNSTERT.2021.02.020

Frith, L., & Blyth, E. (2013). They Can’t Have My Embryo: The Ethics of Conditional Embryo Donation. Bioethics, 27(6), 317–324. https://doi.org/10.1111/BIOE.12034

Gabriel, I. (2016). Effective Altruism and its Critics. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 34(4), 457–473. https://doi.org/10.1111/JAPP.12176

Garrett, K. A., Alcalá-Brisenõ, R. I., Andersen, K. F., Brawner, J., Choudhury, R. A., Delaquis, E., Fayette, J., Poudel, R., Purves, D., Rothschild, J., Small, I. M., Thomas-Sharma, S., & Xing, Y. (2020). Effective Altruism as an Ethical Lens on Research Priorities. Phytopathology, 110(4), 708–722. https://doi.org/10.1094/PHYTO-05-19-0168-RVW

Go, K. J., Romanski, P. A., Bortoletto, P., Patel, J. C., Srouji, S. S., & Ginsburg, E. S. (2023). Meeting the challenge of unclaimed cryopreserved embryos. Fertility and Sterility, 119(1), 15–20. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.FERTNSTERT.2022.09.323

Goold, I., & Savulescu, J. (2009). IN FAVOUR OF FREEZING EGGS FOR NON-MEDICAL REASONS. Bioethics, 23(1), 47–58. https://doi.org/10.1111/J.1467-8519.2008.00679.X

Gouveia, C., Huyser, C., Egli, D., & Pepper, M. S. (2020). Lessons learned from somatic cell nuclear transfer. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 21(7). https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms21072314

Gryshchenko, M., Parashchuk, V., & Blockeel, C. (2023). The impact of war on reproductive medicine in Ukraine. Reproductive BioMedicine Online, 47(4). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rbmo.2023.103306

Hammarberg, K., & Tinney, L. (2006). Deciding the fate of supernumerary frozen embryos: a survey of couples’ decisions and the factors influencing their choice. Fertility and Sterility, 86(1), 86–91. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.FERTNSTERT.2005.11.071

Hoang, D. M., Pham, P. T., Bach, T. Q., Ngo, A. T. L., Nguyen, Q. T., Phan, T. T. K., Nguyen, G. H., Le, P. T. T., Hoang, V. T., Forsyth, N. R., Heke, M., & Nguyen, L. T. (2022). Stem cell-based therapy for human diseases. Signal Transduction and Targeted Therapy 2022 7:1, 7(1), 1–41. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41392-022-01134-4

Hu, K. L., Hunt, S., Zhang, D., Li, R., & Mol, B. W. (2022). The association between embryo storage time and treatment success in women undergoing freeze-all embryo transfer. Fertility and Sterility, 118(3), 513–521. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2022.06.003

Huele, E. H., Kool, E. M., Bos, A. M. E., Fauser, B. C. J. M., & Bredenoord, A. L. (2020). The ethics of embryo donation: what are the moral similarities and differences of surplus embryo donation and double gamete donation? Human Reproduction, 35(10), 2171–2178. https://doi.org/10.1093/HUMREP/DEAA166

Jaycox, M. P. (2012). Coercion, autonomy, and the preferential option for the poor in the ethics of organ transplantation. Developing World Bioethics, 12(3), 135–147. https://doi.org/10.1111/J.1471-8847.2012.00327.X

Kovacs, G. T., Morgan, G., Wood, E. C., Forbes, C., & Howlett, D. (2003). Community attitudes to assisted reproductive technology: a 20-year trend. The Medical Journal of Australia, 179(10), 536–538. https://doi.org/10.5694/J.1326-5377.2003.TB05680.X

Lawlor, R. (2014). Organ sales: exploitative at any price? Bioethics, 28(4), 194–202. https://doi.org/10.1111/BIOE.12000

Lovell-Badge, R., Anthony, E., Barker, R. A., Bubela, T., Brivanlou, A. H., Carpenter, M., Charo, R. A., Clark, A., Clayton, E., Cong, Y., Daley, G. Q., Fu, J., Fujita, M., Greenfield, A., Goldman, S. A., Hill, L., Hyun, I., Isasi, R., Kahn, J., … Zhai, X. (2021). ISSCR Guidelines for Stem Cell Research and Clinical Translation: The 2021 update. Stem Cell Reports, 16(6), 1398–1408. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.STEMCR.2021.05.012

MacCallum, F., Golombok, S., & Brinsden, P. (2007). Parenting and child development in families with a child conceived through embryo donation. Journal of Family Psychology : JFP : Journal of the Division of Family Psychology of the American Psychological Association (Division 43), 21(2), 278–287. https://doi.org/10.1037/0893-3200.21.2.278

Miklavcic, J. J., & Flaman, P. (2017). Personhood status of the human zygote, embryo, fetus. The Linacre Quarterly, 84(2), 130. https://doi.org/10.1080/00243639.2017.1299896

Perrotta, M., & Hamper, J. (2023). Patient informed choice in the age of evidence‐based medicine: IVF patients’ approaches to biomedical evidence and fertility treatment add‐ons. Sociology of Health & Illness, 45(2), 225. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9566.13581

Quigley, T. (2024). Why restrict medical effective altruism? Bioethics, 38(5), 452–459. https://doi.org/10.1111/BIOE.13279

Rienzi, L., Gracia, C., Maggiulli, R., Labarbera, A. R., Kaser, D. J., Ubaldi, F. M., Vanderpoel, S., & Racowsky, C. (2017). Oocyte, embryo and blastocyst cryopreservation in ART: systematic review and meta-analysis comparing slow-freezing versus vitrification to produce evidence for the development of global guidance. Human Reproduction Update, 23(2), 139. https://doi.org/10.1093/HUMUPD/DMW038

Rivron, N. C., Martinez Arias, A., Pera, M. F., Moris, N., & M’hamdi, H. I. (2023). An ethical framework for human embryology with embryo models. Cell, 186(17), 3548–3557. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.CELL.2023.07.028

Simopoulou, M., Sfakianoudis, K., Giannelou, P., Rapani, A., Maziotis, E., Tsioulou, P., Grigoriadis, S., Simopoulos, E., Mantas, D., Lambropoulou, M., Koutsilieris, M., Pantos, K., & Harper, J. C. (2019). Discarding IVF embryos: reporting on global practices. Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics, 36(12), 2447. https://doi.org/10.1007/S10815-019-01592-W

Singer, P. (2015). The Most Good You Can Do: How Effective Altruism is Changing Ideas About Living Ethically. The Most Good You Can Do. https://doi.org/10.12987/9780300182415

Stuhmcke, A. (2014). Tick Tock Goes the Clock: Rethinking Policy and Embryo Storage Limits. Feminist Legal Studies, 22(3), 285–306. https://doi.org/10.1007/S10691-014-9273-1/METRICS

Taylor, J. S. (2009). Autonomy and organ sales, revisited. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 34(6), 632–648. https://doi.org/10.1093/JMP/JHP044

Tonkens, R. (2018). Effective altruists ought to be allowed to sell their kidneys. Bioethics, 32(3), 147–154. https://doi.org/10.1111/BIOE.12427

Villalba, A., Rueda, J., & de Miguel Beriain, Í. (2023). Synthetic embryos: a new venue in ethical research. Reproduction, 165(4), V1–V3. https://doi.org/10.1530/rep-22-0416

Wånggren, K., Alden, J., Bergh, T., & Skoog Svanberg, A. (2013). Attitudes towards embryo donation among infertile couples with frozen embryos. Human Reproduction (Oxford, England), 28(9), 2432–2439. https://doi.org/10.1093/HUMREP/DET252

Zakrzewski, W., Dobrzyński, M., Szymonowicz, M., & Rybak, Z. (2019). Stem cells: Past, present, and future. Stem Cell Research and Therapy, 10(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13287-019-1165-5

Zhang, X., Wu, S., Hao, G., Wu, X., Ren, H., Zhang, Y., Yang, A., Bi, X., Bai, L., Zhang, Y., & Tan, J. (2021). Prolonged Cryopreservation Negatively Affects Embryo Transfer Outcomes Following the Elective Freeze-All Strategy: A Multicenter Retrospective Study. Frontiers in Endocrinology, 12, 709648. https://doi.org/10.3389/FENDO.2021.709648/FULL